Sunday, 14 October 2012

Battle Report: Wargaming Borodino 2012 (12)

NOTE: This is the full report of our bicentennial game of Borodino originally posted in October 2012.

Other posts about our bicentennial game of Borodino include:
• the initial report done soon afterwards,
• a list of links to the files that we used in the game, and
• a pictorial report of the game posted one year on.


After all the planning, we began our big Borodino bash at about 21:00 AWST on Friday night, the 7th September, 200 years to the day; albeit about 12 hours later than the beginning of the battle on that fateful day in 1812. Initially we had four players; Stephen, Mark, Julian and me, but knew that we had two more commanders arriving at 'first light' on Saturday. I was always going to be on the French-Allied side, but everyone else wanted to be Russian! Julian decided he would join me while Mark (aka Kutusov) and Stephen (aka Barclay de Tolly) would take the Russians.


Bird's-eye view from a tree in the Utitsa woods. The bird must have been wondering what all these humans were up to...

Initial positions Stroganov's grenadiers


Starting positions viewed from the south-west: Poles of V Corps partially in right foreground, Davout's I Corps in centre,  with Bruyere's and Valence's divisions of Nansouty's I Reserve Cavalry Corps behind them


Initial positions viewed from the north-east: Russian reserve artillery on the left, combined grenadier battalions of V Corps in the centre with Korf's II Cav in front of them
Initial view of Borodino village from the Russian lines, Bakhmetyev III's 23rd Division in the foreground

Initial positions in the centre of the battlefield. Flêches at the top right, Grand Redoubt in the left distance
Initial positions of the Russian army (troops are behind the flêches)
Ornano's cavalry division occupying the extreme left of the French-Allied line
Three close-up photos of Mark's Hat Bavarians, for Ben :-)



Amazingly, with all the planning and preparation, I had arrived on that Friday evening with only a hazy battle plan. This formed into what I thought was a clearer plan of action as I surveyed the table while we set-up the off-board troops of the French-Allied army. My eventual plan was pretty close to history (as our set-up, victory conditions and restrictions encouraged). Poniatowski was to clear Utitsa and become the right flank of the attack, Compans' and Dessaix's divisions of Davout's corps were to attack the flêches from around the south side, Broussier ("the bruiser's") division of Eugène's corps was to assault and take Borodino while Delzons’ division (IV Corps), supported by Morand's, was to assault the Grand Redoubt from the north supported by Ney's corps from the south. I conferred with Julian (aka Prince Eugène) and explained my plan. "I'm not sure, but if it comes off mon Empereur it will be a great plan". Fabulous moral support there from my reluctant sub-commander!

“Kutusov's” plan was, obviously, to defend the key points of the Grand Redoubt and flêches, using tactical reserves as necessary. He also intended to move troops to support the guard jägers in Borodino, or to retake the town if it had been captured by the Franco-Allied forces. Further north, Platov and Uvarov's flank attack was to create as much mayhem as possible on the left flank of Napoleon's army. In the south, Stroganov's grenadier division would move to support Konovnitsyn’s defense of the town and mound of Utitsa.

After completing the final set-up, admiring our work and issuing orders we began this much anticipated game.
Inspiration: Roubaud's panorama
View from the north early in the battle; no sign of Platov and Uvarov... as yet
Early stages of the battle, from the SW
Taking our time, and plenty of photos, we played the first two turns (hours) of the game on that first night. When 'stumps' was declared in the early hours of Saturday morning, Borodino had been captured and was still held by Broussier's division and pleasing progress had been made towards the three key objectives of the Grand Redoubt, flêches and Utitsa, with minimal losses to Russian artillery. As a bonus, Karpov II's weak cossack 'division' on the extreme Russian left (south of Utitsa) had been broken. "We could not have expected it to have gone any better for the French", Eugène remarked.
IV Corps attacks Borodino and advances towards Grand Redoubt
French capture Borodino
Bug Cossacks, Karpov II's Division
Polish hussars and chasseurs confront Karpov II's Cossacks (lancers in retreat after having lost first mêlée)
Kaminski's Polish hussars in their successful attack

Mark's beautifully painted Strelets hussars, Saxons doubling as Poles (note stagger and blown markers)
Ney's III Corps (centre and left) and Dessaix's division mount their initial attacks
View of same from Russian lines

Next day, Peter and Rod joined us as planned. After explaining the situation of the battle, determining which troops they would command—Rod the Russian centre and left (i.e. Bagration's Second Western Army) and Peter the attack on Utitsa (i.e. Poniatowski's Poles)—and giving them a brief introduction to the rules, we began again.

The relative luck of the French-Allied side from the night before now seemed to have evaporated. Razout's division of Ney's corps was mauled by Russian artillery fire from the vicinity of Semenoskoye. These losses were too much for Razout's men, who failed morale and retreated on Turn 4 (0900).


Approach of Platov and Uvarov
Initial attack on Grand Redoubt
Dessaix's initial attack on flêches

Russian defense of Utitsa
Attack of V Corps
Zayonchek's skirmishers go into action
The battle entered its ‘arm-wrestle’ phase over the next two turns (1000–1100), with successes for both sides. In the north, Eugène’s troops were fighting desperately on three ‘fronts’. Uvarov and Platov's flank attack was going well; Ornano's cavalry division n'existe plus and Chastel's cavalry was in trouble. Broussier’s men had thus far resisted all that the Russians could throw at them across the narrow Borodino bridgehead and continued to hold the town. However, the attacks by Delzons’ and Morand’s divisions on the Grand Redoubt were repulsed with ease by Rayevski’s men.

Platov and Uvarov's attack
Platov leads his men to the attack
Platov's Cossacks with Uvarov's I Cavalry Corps in support
Cossack's on the attack
Uvarov's Life Guard Hussars

La Houssaye's dragoons advance to meet Russian threat
Russian counter-attack on Borodino
Compans' troops attack Konovnitsyn and Stroganov's defenders

View of same from south of Utitsa
Girardin's chasseurs retreat having failed to break one of Stroganov's grenadier units on the Utitsa mound
Zayonchek's attack on Utitsa builds
The most significant Russian successes came in the centre, care of Siever's cavalry. The whole of Ney’s corps, was looking decidedly fragile after Wollwrath's chasseurs and lancers were ‘brushed’ aside by the Russian horsemen and then the Kharkovskii dragoons, thanks to yet another ‘6’, rode down a square of Württemberg infantry from Marchand’s small division.
Kharkovskii dragoons attack Württembergers in square. Note 6 on die...
... and the result

All was not disastrous though thanks to some promising developments for the French-Allies in the south, where Kniaziewicz and Compans combined to push back Stroganov’s grenadier’s before Utitsa; although the Russians still held the town. Crucially though, Compans was allowing his division to become more and more engrossed in the “side-show” of Utitsa, at the expense of his attack on the flêches.

Lithuanian (Litovskii) uhlans attack flank of Dessaix
Turn 7, 1200, was a great one for the Russians. Not to be outdone by the Kharkovskii dragoons, Sievers’ Lithuanian (Litovskii) uhlans effectively broke Dessaix's command single-handedly after riding down not one, but two squares that had been hastily formed by the harassed and weakened infantry units from that division! To add to the insult to Ney’s prestige, Wollwrath's cavalry division failed to rally and routed off table. There was now a large gap in the French-Allied centre. 


Poniatowski and staff
Yet it seemed that the situation could be stabilised, at least, and perhaps even turned to a better outcome. I was speaking to Peter (Poniatowski) following the dramatic events described above, and just prior to our break for a late dinner. It seemed to me that we could send in a hammer blow from the south to presssure Utitsa and the flêches in the form of his troops and Compans' and Friant’s divisions (from Davout, aka me) supported by the reserve cavalry which had just been ordered, successfully, to drive between the flêches and Grand Redoubt.


Ah, but how quickly things can change...

The Russian successes from Turn 7 continued into Turn 8 (1300). Following up on their previous success, units of Kniaziewicz’s and Compans’ divisions once again attacked Stronganov’s grenadiers, this time only to be broken by the stout defence of the St Petersburg grenadiers. The only glimmer of light for the French-Allied forces came from Pajol's hussars that broke a unit of Russian hussars and followed up to break the Lithuanian uhlans (the victors of mêlées in Turn 6).

The biggest blow to the French-Allied cause came in the Command Phase when a ‘1’ was rolled for Compans’ division, leading it to fail morale and to retreat. A comparable test for the Russians saw Mecklemburg’s division, which was defending the flêches, pass morale at 1/3 losses.
Russian defensive lines late in the battle
Nansouty's reserve cavalry corps

French reserve cavalry on the move
From the Russian side. The attack was too late to have the desired effect 
Frian't final, successful attack on the Grand Redoubt
The period from 1400 to 1600 was a tough few hours on the French-Allied side. Osterman-Tolstoy’s IV Corps regained Borodino, Broussier's division (Eugène’s IV Corps) was finally broken and Zayocek's division (Poniatowski’s V Corps) was initially demoralised (1500) and then broken (1600) along with Delzons division (IV Corps). The cavalry mêlées in the centre which initially pitted Pajol’s French light cavalry against Sievers dragoons and then Borozdin II’s 1st Cuirassier Division resulted in Russian victories. It was not completely one-way traffic though as Mecklemburg's division retreated from flêches, Paskevich’s division (Rayevski’s VII Corps) and Bakhmetyev I’s division of Osterman-Tolstoy’s IV Corps were demoralised and Konovnitsyn’s small division retreated from the Utitsa woods. We called an end to the day’s gaming at that point (2 am on Sunday morning). We had one more turn of the game left to play at that point; if we bothered.

The last straw, three 6s when a 4 or below required 
The result was not good for the Vistula legion!
Of course, things always look different in the cold, hard light of day and I/we realised that we'd kick ourselves if we did not complete the last turn, however futile and painful it may prove to be for the French-Allied side. Just as well as it turned out to be quite a monumental final turn.

The flêches were taken by Friant’s troops and Ponitowski’s men finally captured the Utitsa mount. The run of inopportune die rolls continued for the French-Allies when Eugène, attempting to form square with three battalions of the Vistula Legion rolled three 6s (requiring 4 or below to succeed)! In the north, IV Corps was looking terribly fragile with only the Italian Guard and Gerard’s division remaining as effective fighting forces. At the end of the turn (Command Phase) Mecklemburg's division rallied as did Konovnitsyn’s. Stroganov’s grenadiers were demoralised and Kaminiski's cavalry (Polish V Corps) retreated.


Battle's end: view from NE

Battle's end: view from north
Battle's end: view from south

Battle's end: view from SW
Battle's end: Grand Redoubt
So ended our bicentennial Borodino game. While it did not go in any way according to plan for the French-Allies, it was a near perfect action for the Russians. By our scenario the result of the game was a Russian tactical victory (see previously posted description). This seemed appropriate as, while the French-Allied attack was severely blunted, there was a large part of the army that remained unengaged. On the Russian side, the front-line troops had suffered great loss, but more than half of the army was unengaged. Had we had the time, energy and inclination, it would have been interesting to have continued the battle until dark on that September day (another three or four turns). Oh well, another time...!


As regular readers of this blog will know, we had been planning and preparing this game for months. All of the time that went into it, including the three days of playing the game, were well worth it.

I’d like to make special mention of Mark’s efforts to make this game possible. For him this game was over 30 years in the planning. It would not have been possible without his superhuman effort in painting the extra Russians that we needed for the battle. He painted about 900 figures in six months, peaking at nearly 100 in a week! Unfortunately, I did not work as steadily on the French-Allied units and failed in my 11th-hour attempts to catch up (the undercoated and partially painted figures in the photos are all down to me). Julian’s Borodino church deserves another mention. It was a real feature of the battlefield and of the photos. A final thanks to Rod, Peter and Stephen for being part of the game and to Stephen for his photos, many of which feature in this post.

Having completed this little effort in 2012 our thoughts and attentions are now turning to the big one; Leipzig in 2013, hopefully also at 1:50 and 2mm to 1m!


This is my last post about our game to commemorate the Borodino bicentennial. I will close it with some photos of various units and other 'points of interest' from the game.


Duka II's Russian 1st Cuirassier Division

Lorge's heavy cavalry division (Saxon heavies leading)

Miffy enjoying spring sunshine, oblivious to the events occurring inside

Some Russian gunners had time for a lie down!

While others worked hard to bring guns into action

Russian artillery reserve; idol all day

Sievers hussars (represented by the Pavlograd Hussars)

Sievers Akhtyrskskii Hussars

Junot's VIII (Westphalian) Corps in reserve all day
The skies above Borodino!

A Vulcan does a fly-over

Another view

Crowded skies

ANF HQ

Our version of Buçaco ridge




28 comments:

  1. Ouaouh!!!!!!!
    Great, huge and impressive battle! Very nice pictures James, with many many lovely figures!
    It seems that you had a lot of fun...and a lot of 6!
    My favourite photo : "Ney's III Corps (centre and left) and Dessaix's division mount their initial attacks"...
    Best,
    Phil.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We did have a lot of fun Phil, although it was the Russian players who had fun with the sixes!!

      Photos showing massed troops are always good aren't they?

      Delete
  2. Fantastic set up James.. Very inspiring.

    Steve

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Steve. It has certainly inspired us!

      Delete
  3. Another great post - really superb stuff, I'm very much looking forward to seeing your Leipzig game develop!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Most kind Stryker. I'll try to have a post about our preliminary table/board design for Leipzig soon.

      Delete
  4. AWESOME!

    Truly AWESOME work gentlemen.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks MurdocK. It is a pleasure to share it with others, especially when we receive such encouraging feedback!

      Delete
  5. Very very impressive photos. What an awesome table.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Rodger. We'll look forward to seeing developments for your Gettysburg game.

      Delete
  6. Great looking table, and wonderful report, James. Only thing missing was a French victory! Bravo!

    So you only had SIX players for this huge game? I think we had 14, and could have used a few more.... plus another 4 hours of playing time.

    WE have, in a rare moment of sanity, decided against attempting Leipzig, or at least the "full Monty". I am still intent on doing Dresden, with taking some liberties on the force composition.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Couldn't agree more Peter (about the missing victory!).

      I'll be intrigued to see your plans for and game of Dresden. I am trying to recall if there was much fighting in the city? I seem to recall that the French-Allies 'sallied forth' around several points?

      Delete
  7. Well done! I can see that a tremendous amount of work went into this project. Thank you for taking the time to document and post the results.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Scott and thanks to you for your great blog with all those eyewitness accounts.

      Delete
  8. Impressive results! One of those games where you think wish I could have seen that live!

    ReplyDelete
  9. You MUST come and join us sometime David. It'd be great to have you involved.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes next weekend your meeting let me know I'm there!

      Delete
  10. WOW James,
    That is some mass of troops and a great looking battlefield (I see there are still some WIP figures so some hope for us all yet!). Nice to see your collection of aircraft too (many I will have built myself over the years) and your wee dog.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Paul. Ah yes, sadly the WIP figures were all down to me... the model planes are Julian's, the pooch is Mark's (Julian's and mine being out of photo and not present respectively)!

      Delete
  11. Its good to see WIP figures in Bat Reps, gives me the feeling that others are still thinking what units to add to their collection.

    ReplyDelete
  12. My buddy Robert has massed 1000's of 15mm naps over the years and when I asked him when will he have enough his reply was when he is dead so its always good to see new figures in joining a collection! ;-)

    ReplyDelete
  13. Earlier this year some wag on the Hat forum asked how many figures were enough. "That does not compute"! Most people, including us, were bemused at the idea!

    I do however expect a time when one looks at expected longevity and painting output and decide that enough is enough... perhaps!

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hi James, a super report here, I enjoyed every minute of it. Your photo's are a great uniform guide! Very handy! Heads-up to Mark the painter and his tireless/thankless work slaving away... only for you to lose the battle and not even engage half the painted Russians! You must owe him like ten thousand dollars or somethin. I suggest you pay up! ;>

    Oh, the markers for cavalry; blown, staggered. . BRILLIANT!

    Thanks for the time and effort to post James!

    Regards

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks so much for such encouraging comments. It's great that you not only found it interesting, but also useful.

      Yeah, it was a bummer that many of the figures did not get used in 'anger', especially those beautiful heavy cav.; of both sides. They might have if the Russian players had been more accommodating with their die rolls (or if we'd rolled better when they did give us a roll that gave our boys a chance)! ;) Ah well, next time Moriarty...!!!

      Delete
  15. I missed you AAR until today.... What a great game!
    Thanks for sharing
    Rafa

    ReplyDelete
  16. Glad that you liked it Rafa. We had a great time preparing and playing the game. Hopefully Leipzig will work as well.

    ReplyDelete