Wednesday, 28 January 2015

Battle of Vimeiro, 21st August 1808

Our first game for 2015, the ‘traditional’ Australia Day game, was a re-fight of the Battle of Vimeiro using Chris Leach’s Fields of Glory scenario and Zimmermann’s The Wargamer’s Handbook rules.

As with the real thing, the French made piece-meal attacks, but managed to turn what looked like certain defeat early in the game into a victory by turn (hour) six. A better second half performance, aided by some helpful combinations of good and bad luck, plus British inertia on the ridge, lead to this history-changing result.

Here’s how it came to pass…


We set up according to the scenario but, in using Zimmermann’s rules, we had variably sized units, based on the strengths from orders of battle, scaled at 1:33.

Photo 1: Looking east down the field of battle, British at left, French at right. Vimeiro in the left foreground, Toledo in the centre and Ventosa in the distance at left.

Photo 2: View of the French side of the battlefield. Brigades (left to right) Charlot, Thomières, army artillery (223 guns), Kellermann (grénadiers réunis) and Solignac in the distance on the isolated ridge.
The green block (purple in photo 1) is to expunge Montmorand's brigade that I incorrectly placed, discovering my error in the second turn—more on that later!

Photos 3 & 4: Close-up of the French troops in the western and eastern sectors.

Photos 5 & 6: On the other side of the battlefield, Anstruther’s and Fane’s brigades defend the area west of Vimeiro (above) supported by Acland’s and Nightingall’s brigades, plus Taylor with the 20th light dragoons, east of the town.

Photo 7: Ferguson’s artillery fired at the exposed end of Solignac’s line, but a 1 for windage saved them.

Photo 8: Thomières’ men were not so lucky, Fane’s artillery causing losses to the 2/86e ligne. Note dice for windage (white) and effect (red).

Photo 9: The French batteries tried some counter-battery fire, missing everything. The range was too far to be effective, so move forward they must…

Photo 10: Junot ordered Charlot’s and Thomières’ brigades to attack, supported by the incorrectly placed troops of Montmorand (pale green box).

Photo 11: The mistake rectified, the French attack did not look nearly so imposing!

Photo 12: Overview of the battlefield viewed from the north-west.

Photo 13: A dramatic third cycle (hour) began with a fire-fight between Charlot’s 3/82e ligne and Anstruther’s 2/97th (represented by another unit). A die is used for each group of six figures firing, white for a partial group at half-effect. Displaced figures show the casualties. Casualties inflicted increase for die rolls from one to three and again from four to six.

Photos 14 & 15: Thomières’ lead units attacked Fane’s men, the 2/86e losing their mêlée, while the 1/86e won theirs (dice indicating the random factor in each mêlée).

Photo 15: Anstruther’s and Fane’s brigades retreated from the western end of the ridge-line having failed their morale tests at 1/4 and 1/3 losses. Meanwhile, Thomières’ brigade passed at 1/2 losses...

Photo 16: … thus remained in sole possession of the ridge.

Photo 17: Could they make it to Vimeiro to secure it for the French?

“It’s never a good tactic to throw 1s for morale tests!” Mark remarked.

Photo 18: Overview of the battlefield, this time looking from the south-east.

Photo 19: On the French right (eastern) flank, Montmorand’s brigade finally arrived—at the correct location this time!

Photo 20: View from Nightingall’s position west of Ventosa, as Wellesley sends Bowes’ brigade (foreground) to sure up his right.

Photo 21: Junot hurries Kellermann’s grénadiers to support Thomières’ depleted troops, and repositions the guns to fire at the British right-centre.

Photo 22: Overview of the battlefield at the end of the 4th cycle (hour).

Photo 23 & 24: The next cycle was mainly taken up with manoeuvring, along with some deadly fire from the re-positioned French guns. Here the view from Acland’s position showing the mass of the French guns, Kellermann’s grenadiers réunis and the newly-arrived cavalry of Margaron.

Photo 25 & 26: In the eastern sector, Montmorand’s brigade continued its advance towards Ferguson’s position, now supported by the arrival of Catlin Craufurd’s brigade and Trant’s Portugese. The cavalry of the latter having forced Montmorand’s 2/70e ligne to form square.

Photo 27: Casualties from the French artillery forced a morale test for Acland’s brigade. Another 1 result meant that they too quit the field.

Photo 28 & 29: Wellesley’s right flank was now severely compromised.

Photo 30: Thomières’ brigade occupied both sectors of Vimeiro.

Photo 31: This geographic objective, coupled with the loss of three British infantry brigades (plus Taylor’s cavalry which was to also retreat having been reduced to half-strength and failed the morale test) left the French in a strong position.

Photo 32: In the east Solignac’s orders arrived, so his brigade moved off in support of Montmorand’s attack.

Photo 33: View from Ferguson’s position.

Photo 34: Close-up of Montmorand’s 3/2e légère.

Not wishing to sacrifice his army in a do or die effort, Wellesley ordered his remaining troops to retire from the field. The scenario result was a major French victory, which was downgraded to a victory as Junot had called on Margaron’s cavalry.

Photo 35: Overview of the table at battle’s end.

Photo 36: Nightingall’s brigade standing strong to cover the withdrawal.

It was a fast-paced game without being ‘fast play’ and served to increase my liking of the overall mechanics and many of the specific mechanisms in the Zimmermann rules. We now plan to re-play the scenario, using our ANF version of Shako. It will be a most interesting comparison.

17 comments:

  1. Major French Victory? Wellington's withdrawal? "Bravo les Français!!"...and Bravo to you, great looking game!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Phil. I was most surprised by the result as it looked like it was going to go the other way around the second turn. Mark's poor rolling for brigade morale decided the day!
      With three brigades to one 'broken' and Vimeiro taken it would have been a 'major victory' by the scenario, but I had called upon Margaron's cavalry, which reduced the level to 'victory'. The Fields of Glory scenarios are nicely balanced by victory conditions (and/or modified dispositions) to make a win possible for either side.

      Delete
  2. Good BatRep, James and excellent game!

    I have replayed this battle more than any other Napoleonic contest. The French are STILL awaiting their first vctory on my table.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Jonathan. You need to encourage the British player to throw a few 1s!

      Delete
    2. Quite right, James! I do look forward to your replay with Shako.

      Delete
  3. James - if Wellington lost there is something wrong with rules! Great looking game.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Cheers Ian!
    That's a big part of the reason we wargame, n'est pas?!
    I realise that you are largely tongue in cheek. As we know, with nearly any battle that we care to investigate, they were closer than a one line summary indicates. Wellesley may well have lost... if he'd thrown a few more 1s!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Enjoyed the report and the French victory. Much the same thing in Piquet/FoB - Even with a big advantage, "you can always roll a 1!"

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Peter. It's a good day for your own side when the opponent throws several of them, haha!!! :)

      Delete
  6. I'm not familiar with FoG (except the Ancients rules) or the Zimmermann rules, but Vimeiro was one of the first battles that I read an AAR about. It was really exciting until much later I found that Guard cavalry and heaps other units were not actually part of the battles...

    I'm trying really hard to focus on Waterloo, but I've been distracted by Marengo and now this. :-)

    I recently picked up the Napoleon's Battles III scenario disks and the Vimerio scenario which is included looks totally different. I'll email you map so you can see what I mean.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Make, it will be different, but not too different. One of the beauties of Chris Leach's scenarios in Fields of Glory (which, by the way pre-dates the ancients rules, hehe!) is that he has squared off the battle maps and simplified the terrain to include only the key features. He also manipulates the orders of battle to create a game based on the actual battle with victory conditions that make it possible for either side to emerge victorious--albeit usually more difficult for the losing side in the real thing. That's why the victory conditions in this one were adjusted for the use of Margaron's cavalry (dragoons and chasseurs).
      There weren't any guard cav. though. Are you thinking of Fuentes de Onoro? Or were you referring to the tendency of young wargamers to have a high proportion of guard in their armies? haha!

      Delete
    2. I would be interested to have a look one day. Meanwhile I've sent you the Napoleon's Battles map.

      As to the Guard cavalry, it was the 1970s and I think they were using what figures they had (not unlike young wargamers, but I am pretty sure they were young, but of course younger than they are now if they are still with us - Mal Wright from Adelaide I think was the lead/author. I used to use his rules - Chain and Ball or maybe Bayonet? Can't remember. I'm now wondering if I still have the article somewhere, maybe even the rules.)

      Delete
    3. Yeah, the days when we could field about four units and two of them were guard!!

      Delete
  7. Bravo! Excellent AAR. Great to see the classic plastic in action, plus some of the new ones. Spotted Revell, House of Campaign, Esci/Italeri and, of course, good old Airfix. Sounds like a great day was had by all. Well done ANF.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks! Like your good selves we are devotees of the 'one true scale' (haha) and really enjoy the ease, economy, light-weight and moulding of the plastic figures, new and old.
      I've only had a quick look at your recent game of Ligny but will have a 'proper' look and read in due course. It looks marvellous, as ever!
      [Readers: check this link to see what I mean http://servicerationdistributionhobby.blogspot.com.au/2015/01/ligny-clash-of-wills-bills-part-one.html#comment-form]

      Delete
  8. Very cool James. Who was Wellington in this one? He ought to be flogged!
    (Love your airfix Brits Mark)

    ReplyDelete